Creamy Vanilla Taffy

Regular price $4.49

Our Creamy Vanilla flavor is a classic! Enjoy taffy without the excessive sugar and artificial ingredients and WITH protein and vitamins (naturally!).

Want to try every flavor and get free shipping?

Try the taffy lover's variety pack

Try all of our six flavors, save $2.94 AND GET FREE SHIPPING!

all natural

low sugar

high protein

gluten free

the numa difference

Numa Laffy Taffy Hi Chew
all natural Yes No No
sugar 8g 14g 16g
protein 2g 0g 0g
vitamins 5-10 0 0

What our customers have to say

These are such a tasty snack, and I love that they have less sugar and use all natural ingredients that make a healthier snack for my children (and me) rather than the typical sugary snack. Perfect for taking on the go!

Like a taste of my childhood, but healthier! Love that I can feel better about eating these.

Sooooo delicious! Hard to stop at just one piece, very natural tasting!

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews
Danny Kubert

Wouldn’t change a thing!

Michele Osherow
Good taffy

I don’t think the vanilla is as off-the-charts fantastic as the other flavors, but a yummy treat, nonetheless

A “vanilla” that tastes like a milk shake w/less sugar!

I asked about vanilla and now it’s here. Not too sweet. No bitter after-taste. Soft, but chewy. Flavor lasts long after the candy is gone.

Kristie McGovern
Not as I expected

I absolutely love Numa taffy. So when I heard that they were coming out with a vanilla taffy, I was ecstatic as that is my favorite flavor in the world. To my disappointment it is missing that vanilla flavor. Will not be buying again.


Your straight Vanilla Taffy is good. I'm glad it had no peanuts for I can't eat peanuts. The flavor was mild so I would not mind a bit more flavor and is one to keep in mind when purchasing. It may not be my favorite but not my least favorite favorite.